July 28, 2016

Ahold Delhaize has a red letter day

Ahold Delhaize celebrates its first day on Euronext in Amsterdam (photo: Euronext)
Married at last: After a 13-month wait for cartel office approval on both sides of the Atlantic, Ahold Delhaize celebrates its début on the Euronext exchange in Amsterdam this Monday (photo: Euronext)
Perhaps Ahold Delhaize were guided by the spirit of the English saying: "One for a wish, Two for a kiss, Three for a letter..."?

But, whatever the motivation, on the very first workday after leading Dutch grocer Ahold and number two Belgian retailer Delhaize merged last weekend, they sent a "welcome letter" to their top 100 suppliers in the Benelux expressing a heartfelt desire for "a good future relationship".

In the brutal cut and thrust of modern-day business this kind of thing can only bring tears to one's eyes. After all, love between retailers and manufacturers is as beautiful as it is rare. Doubtless, however, all was in a good cause. For how else could this new retail giant give expression to its joy now that it posts around €63bn in annual sales in a total of eleven countries, including Germany and, somewhat improbably, Indonesia?

Like children clinging to the hope of Santa Claus on Christmas Eve, trusting food producers and fmcg manufacturers would want to believe that the celebratory letter-writing exercise was motivated by a deep spirit of altruism and brotherly love. But a bad grown-up in the shape of Bernstein has shattered this belief for ever.

Ahold Delhaize CEO Dick Boer and Vice-CEO Frans Muller (photo: Euronext)
Big Bang: CEO Dick Boer (left) and Deputy CEO Frans Muller sound the gong for the start of trade in Ahold Delhaize shares on the Amsterdam bourse (photo: Euronext)
For what does the London-based investment company tell us in a recent research note? We learn that both Ahold and Delhaize employed consultants prior to the completion of the deal in order to create so-called "play books", listing the terms & conditions for each and every line in their assortments.

No smoke without fire. This is truly the stuff that "good future relationships" are made of. It is certainly standard operating procedure for retailers who love a bonus at the best of times, let alone a marriage. And shareholders should expect no less than a harmonisation of buying terms.

The existence of any such play books and a dispatch of letters fit the stated intention of CEO Dick Boer and CFO Jeff Carr to achieve €500m in synergies by July 2019. Around 25 to 30 per cent of the same is to be achieved through the optimisation of operating costs, especially at head office (for which read redundancies). But the lion's share must come from more efficient buying in brands and own label.

As from next week, around 100 of the larger suppliers to the Benelux region are therefore expected to attend "alignment meetings" with Ahold veteran Sebastiaan de Jong, Senior Vice President Sourcing Integration, and his team prior to the commencement of normal annual negotiations as from October. "We expect you to come as soon as we invite you because it is in both our interests that we complete the process quickly," was apparently the phrase used for those suppliers suddenly overanxious to take a very long summer holiday.

The doubtless very jolly meetings will take place in Breda − selected because it is equidistant from the head offices of Ahold and Delhaize in Zaandam viz. Brussels. But this is only a temporary arrangement. In future years, Ahold and Delhaize intend to retain their separate headquarter buying offices as they also wish to keep the former colours and logos of their 22 "local" banners.

Ahold Delhaize head office in Zaandam (photo: Ahold Delhaize)
More leg space: Most redundancies have occurred at head office in Zaandam (photo: Ahold Delhaize)
No decision has been made yet, however, on the fate of Ahold's Albert Heijn stores in Belgium or on European retailer alliance membership. Currently, Ahold belongs to buying group AMS Sourcing, and Delhaize is part of Rewe-dominated alliance Coopernic

Meanwhile, an Ahold Delhaize spokesman stresses "the increased distribution potential" that a merger combining 6,500 stores and nearly €2bn in annual e-commerce sales would bring suppliers. "After all, there are not many retailers who cover both sides of the Atlantic." This is obviously true, as far as it goes, but also sounds suspiciously like a "marriage bonus" argument for the next range review. Here the collective memory of brand manufacturers will doubtless recall Ahold's temporary delisting of major Unilever brands in the past.

At the end of the day, however, it could be that Ahold Delhaize are too sanguine as to how many eggs their 8,000 golden geese suppliers will lay. One former top manager at a major European retailer alliance has his doubts: "The trade press love to talk about the harmonisation of terms & conditions, but in my experience this is only possible on one's own domestic market because terms of trade vary too much from country to country. In the Netherlands, for instance, deals are briefly defined, whereas in France and Spain there are pages and pages."

Ahold Delhaize's new corporate logo (photo: Ahold Delhaize)
Lion king: New corporate logo (photo: Ahold Delhaize)
At any rate, the international investment community seems convinced that Ahold Delhaize management can bring home the bacon. Following its début on the Euronext bourses in Amsterdam (AEX) and Brussels (BEL 20), the opening price for the Ahold Delhaize share was €21.85 on Monday, which implies a market cap of around €28bn. This dwarfs that of several of its peers including Carrefour, whom it is probably destined to replace on the Euro Stoxx 50 at the next review in September.

We shall soon see whether this valuation is justified or not. On November 17 Dick Boer and Jeff Carr will present Q3 results for the first time as a joint company. Just as well they got all those letters off quickly...

Podcast microphone (photo: Gerhard Seybert-Fotolia)
(photo: Gerhard Seybert-Fotolia)

Podcast. Click arrow to listen to an audio version of the text:

Lebensmittel Zeitung with digital sister (photo: LZ)
Our German B2B newspaper, Lebensmittel Zeitung, in print & digital
Read in German: 'Ahold Delhaize will besser einkaufen' by international editor Mike Dawson & features desk manager Jan Mende on page 4 of
Lebensmittel Zeitung, no. 30, 29.07.2016

German Retail Blog

Sign up for your FREE newsletter now!

Comments for this article are closed.

  1. Ruth Raphel
    Created 29 July, 2016 00:40 | Permanent link

    Very well written article and fun to read the "inside stuff".

This is an English-language blog, please write all comments in English!
Thank you.